The Brass Verdict Read online

  “Are you sure? It got a lot of attention.”

  “I been in jail, man.”

  “They don’t have television or newspapers in jail?”

  “I don’t read no papers and the module’s TV been broke since I got there. We made a fuss and they said they’d fix it but they ain’t fixed shit.”

  The judge admonished Torrance to check his language and the witness apologized. I moved on.

  “According to the jail’s records, Mr. Woodson arrived in the high-power module on the fifth of September and, according to the state’s discovery material, you contacted the prosecution on October second to report his alleged confession. Does that sound right to you?”

  “Yeah, that sounds right.”

  “Well, not to me, Mr. Torrance. You are telling this jury that a man accused of a double murder and facing the possible death penalty confessed to a man he had known for less than four weeks?”

  Torrance shrugged before answering.

  “That’s what happened.”

  “So you say. What will you get from the prosecution if Mr. Woodson is convicted of these crimes?”

  “I don’t know. Nobody has promised me nothing.”

  “With your prior record and the charges you currently face, you are looking at more than fifteen years in prison if you’re convicted, correct?”

  “I don’t know about any of that.”

  “You don’t?”

  “No, sir. I let my lawyer handle all that.”

  “He hasn’t told you that if you don’t do something about this, you might go to prison for a long, long time?”

  “He hasn’t told me none of that.”

  “I see. What have you asked the prosecutor for in exchange for your testimony?”

  “Nothing. I don’t want nothing.”

  “So then, you are testifying here because you believe it is your duty as a citizen, is that correct?”

  The sarcasm in my voice was unmistakable.

  “That’s right,” Torrance responded indignantly.

  I held the thick file up over the lectern so he could see it.

  “Do you recognize this file, Mr. Torrance?”

  “No. Not that I recall, I don’t.”

  “You sure you don’t remember seeing it in Mr. Woodson’s cell?”

  “Never been in his cell.”

  “Are you sure that you didn’t sneak in there and look through his discovery file while Mr. Woodson was in the dayroom or in the shower or maybe in court sometime?”

  “No, I did not.”

  “My client had many of the investigative documents relating to his prosecution in his cell. These contained several of the details you testified to this morning. You don’t think that is suspicious?”

  Torrance shook his head.

  “No. All I know is that he sat there at the table and told me what he’d done. He was feeling poorly about it and opened up to me. It ain’t my fault people open up to me.”

  I nodded as if sympathetic to the burden Torrance carried as a man others confided in—especially when it came to double murders.

  “Of course not, Mr. Torrance. Now, can you tell the jury exactly what he said to you? And don’t use the shorthand you used when Mr. Vincent was asking the questions. I want to hear exactly what my client told you. Give us his words, please.”

  Torrance paused as if to probe his memory and compose his thoughts.

  “Well,” he finally said, “we were sittin’ there, the both of us by ourselves, and he just started talkin’ about feelin’ bad about what he’d done. I asked him, ‘What’d you do?’ and he told me about that night he killed the two fellas and how he felt pretty rough about it.”

  The truth is short. Lies are long. I wanted to get Torrance talking in long form, something Vincent had successfully avoided. Jailhouse snitches have something in common with all con men and professional liars. They seek to hide the con in misdirection and banter. They wrap cotton around their lies. But in all of that fluff you often find the key to revealing the big lie.

  Vincent objected again, saying the witness had already answered the questions I was asking and I was simply badgering him at this point.

  “Your Honor,” I responded, “this witness is putting a confession in my client’s mouth. As far as the defense is concerned, this is the case right here. The court would be remiss if it did not allow me to fully explore the content and context of such damaging testimony.”

  Judge Companioni was nodding in agreement before I finished the last sentence. He overruled Vincent’s objection and told me to proceed. I turned my attention back to the witness and spoke with impatience in my voice.

  “Mr. Torrance, you are still summarizing. You claim Mr. Woodson confessed to the murders. So then, tell the jury what he said to you. What were the exact words he said to you when he confessed to this crime?”

  Torrance nodded as if he were just then realizing what I was asking for.

  “The first thing he said to me was ‘Man, I feel bad.’ And I said, ‘For what, my brother?’ He said he kept thinking about those two guys. I didn’t know what he was talking about ’cause, like I said, I hadn’t heard nothin’ about the case, you know? So I said, ‘What two guys?’ and he said, ‘The two niggers I dumped in the reservoir.’ I asked what it was all about and he told me about blasting them both with a shorty and wrappin’ them up in chicken wire and such. He said, ‘I made one bad mistake’ and I asked him what it was. He said, ‘I shoulda taken a knife and opened up their bellies so they wouldn’t end up floatin’ to the top the way they did.’ And that was what he told me.”

  In my peripheral vision I had seen Vincent flinch in the middle of Torrance’s long answer. And I knew why. I carefully moved in with the blade.

  “Did Mr. Woodson use that word? He called the victims ‘niggers’?”

  “Yeah, he said that.”

  I hesitated as I worked on the phrasing of the next question. I knew Vincent was waiting to object if I gave him the opening. I could not ask Torrance to interpret. I couldn’t use the word “why” when it came to Woodson’s meaning or motivation. That was objectionable.

  “Mr. Torrance, in the black community the word ‘nigger’ could mean different things, could it not?”

  “ ’Spose.”

  “Is that a yes?”

  “Yes.”

  “The defendant is African-American, correct?”

  Torrance laughed.

  “Looks like it to me.”

  “As are you, correct, sir?”

  Torrance started to laugh again.

  “Since I was born,” he said.

  The judge tapped his gavel once and looked at me.

  “Mr. Haller, is this really necessary?”

  “I apologize, Your Honor.”

  “Please move on.”

  “Mr. Torrance, when Mr. Woodson used that word, as you say he did, did it shock you?”

  Torrance rubbed his chin as he thought about the question. Then he shook his head.

  “Not really.”

  “Why weren’t you shocked, Mr. Torrance?”

  “I guess it’s ’cause I hear it all a’ time, man.”

  “From other black men?”

  “That’s right. I heard it from white folks, too.”

  “Well, when fellow black men use that word, like you say Mr. Woodson did, who are they talking about?”

  Vincent objected, saying that Torrance could not speak for what other men were talking about. Companioni sustained the objection and I took a moment to rework the path to the answer I wanted.

  “Okay, Mr. Torrance,” I finally said. “Let’s talk only about you, then, okay? Do you use that word on occasion?”

  “I think I have.”

  “All right, and when you have used it, who were you referring to?”

  Torrance shrugged.

  “Other fellas.”

  “Other black men?”

  “That’s right.”

  “Have you ever on occasion referr
ed to white men as niggers?”

  Torrance shook his head.

  “No.”

  “Okay, so then, what did you take the meaning to be when Barnett Woodson described the two men who were dumped in the reservoir as niggers?”

  Vincent moved in his seat, going through the body language of making an objection but not verbally following through with it. He must have known it would be useless. I had led Torrance down the path and he was mine.

  Torrance answered the question.

  “I took it that they were black and he killed ’em both.”

  Now Vincent’s body language changed again. He sank a little bit in his seat because he knew his gamble in putting a jailhouse snitch on the witness stand had just come up snake eyes.

  I looked up at Judge Companioni. He knew what was coming as well.

  “Your Honor, may I approach the witness?”

  “You may,” the judge said.

  I walked to the witness stand and put the file down in front of Torrance. It was legal size, well worn and faded orange—a color used by county jailers to denote private legal documents that an inmate is authorized to possess.

  “Okay, Mr. Torrance, I have placed before you a file in which Mr. Woodson keeps discovery documents provided to him in jail by his attorneys. I ask you once again if you recognize it.”

  “I seen a lotta orange files in high-power. It don’t mean I seen that one.”

  “You are saying you never saw Mr. Woodson with his file?”

  “I don’t rightly remember.”

  “Mr. Torrance, you were with Mr. Woodson in the same module for thirty-two days. You testified he confided in you and confessed to you. Are you saying you never saw him with that file?”

  He didn’t answer at first. I had backed him into a no-win corner. I waited. If he continued to claim he had never seen the file, then his claim of a confession from Woodson would be suspect in the eyes of the jury. If he finally conceded that he was familiar with the file, then he opened a big door for me.

  “What’m saying is that I seen him with his file but I never looked at what was in it.”

  Bang. I had him.

  “Then, I’ll ask you to open the file and inspect it.”

  The witness followed the instruction and looked from side to side at the open file. I went back to the lectern, checking on Vincent on my way. His eyes were downcast and his face was pale.

  “What do you see when you open the file, Mr. Torrance?”

  “One side’s got photos of two bodies on the ground. They’re stapled in there—the photos, I mean. And the other side is a bunch of documents and reports and such.”

  “Could you read from the first document there on the right side? Just read the first line of the summary.”

  “No, I can’t read.”

  “You can’t read at all?”

  “Not really. I didn’t get the schooling.”

  “Can you read any of the words that are next to the boxes that are checked at the top of the summary?”

  Torrance looked down at the file and his eyebrows came together in concentration. I knew that his reading skills had been tested during his last stint in prison and were determined to be at the lowest measurable level—below second-grade skills.

  “Not really,” he said. “I can’t read.”

  I quickly walked over to the defense table and grabbed another file and a Sharpie pen out of my briefcase. I went back to the lectern and quickly printed the word CAUCASIAN on the outside of the file in large block letters. I held the file up so that Torrance, as well as the jury, could see it.

  “Mr. Torrance, this is one of the words checked on the summary. Can you read this word?”

  Vincent immediately stood but Torrance was already shaking his head and looking thoroughly humiliated. Vincent objected to the demonstration without proper foundation and Companioni sustained. I expected him to. I was just laying the groundwork for my next move with the jury and I was sure most of them had seen the witness shake his head.

  “Okay, Mr. Torrance,” I said. “Let’s move to the other side of the file. Could you describe the bodies in the photos?”

  “Um, two men. It looks like they opened up some chicken wire and some tarps and they’re laying there. A bunch a police is there investigatin’ and takin’ pictures.”

  “What race are the men on the tarps?”

  “They’re black.”

  “Have you ever seen those photographs before, Mr. Torrance?”

  Vincent stood to object to my question as having previously been asked and answered. But it was like holding up a hand to stop a bullet. The judge sternly told him he could take his seat. It was his way of telling the prosecutor he was going to have to just sit back and take what was coming. You put the liar on the stand, you take the fall with him.

  “You may answer the question, Mr. Torrance,” I said after Vincent sat down. “Have you ever seen those photographs before?”

  “No, sir, not before right now.”

  “Would you agree that the pictures portray what you described to us earlier? That being the bodies of two slain black men?”

  “That’s what it looks like. But I ain’t seen the picture before, just what he tell me.”

  “Are you sure?”

  “Something like these I wouldn’t forget.”

  “You’ve told us Mr. Woodson confessed to killing two black men, but he is on trial for killing two white men. Wouldn’t you agree that it appears that he didn’t confess to you at all?”

  “No, he confessed. He told me he killed those two.”

  I looked up at the judge.

  “Your Honor, the defense asks that the file in front of Mr. Torrance be admitted into evidence as defense exhibit one.”

  Vincent made a lack-of-foundation objection but Companioni overruled.

  “It will be admitted and we’ll let the jury decide whether Mr. Torrance has or hasn’t seen the photographs and contents of the file.”

  I was on a roll and decided to go all in.

  “Thank you,” I said. “Your Honor, now might also be a good time for the prosecutor to reacquaint his witness with the penalties for perjury.”

  It was a dramatic move made for the benefit of the jury. I was expecting I would have to continue with Torrance and eviscerate him with the blade of his own lie. But Vincent stood and asked the judge to recess the trial while he conferred with opposing counsel.

  This told me I had just saved Barnett Woodson’s life.

  “The defense has no objection,” I told the judge.

  Three

  After the jury filed out of the box, I returned to the defense table as the courtroom deputy was moving in to cuff my client and take him back to the courtroom holding cell.

  “That guy’s a lying sack of shit,” Woodson whispered to me. “I didn’t kill two black guys. They were white.”

  My hope was that the deputy hadn’t heard that.

  “Why don’t you shut the fuck up?” I whispered right back. “And next time you see that lying sack of shit in lockup, you ought to shake his hand. Because of his lies the prosecutor’s about to come off of the death penalty and float a deal. I’ll be back there to tell you about it as soon as I get it.”

  Woodson shook his head dramatically.

  “Yeah, well, maybe I don’t want no deal now. They put a goddamn liar on the stand, man. This whole case should go down the toilet. We can win this motherfucker, Haller. Don’t take no deal.”

  I stared at Woodson for a moment. I had just saved his life but he wanted more. He felt entitled because the state hadn’t played fair—never mind responsibility for the two kids he had just admitted to killing.

  “Don’t get greedy, Barnett,” I told him. “I’ll be back with the news as soon as I get it.”

  The deputy took him through the steel door that led to the holding cells attached to the courtroom. I watched him go. I had no false conceptions about Barnett Woodson. I had never directly asked him but I knew he had kille
d those two Westside boys. That wasn’t my concern. My job was to test the state’s case against him with the best of my skills—that’s how the system worked. I had done that and had been given the blade. I would now use it to improve his situation significantly, but Woodson’s dream of walking away from those two bodies that had turned black in the water was not in the cards. He might not have understood this but his underpaid and underappreciated public defender certainly did.

  After the courtroom cleared, Vincent and I were left looking at each other from our respective tables.

  “So,” I said.

  Vincent shook his head.

  “First of all,” he said. “I want to make it clear that obviously I didn’t know Torrance was lying.”

  “Sure.”

  “Why would I sabotage my own case like this?”

  I waved off the mea culpa.

  “Look, Jerry, don’t bother. I told you in pretrial that the guy had copped the discovery my client had in his cell. It’s common sense. My guy wouldn’t have said shit to your guy, a perfect stranger, and everybody knew it except you.”

  Vincent emphatically shook his head.

  “I did not know it, Haller. He came forward, was vetted by one of our best investigators, and there was no indication of a lie, no matter how improbable it would seem that your client talked to him.”

  I laughed that off in an unfriendly way.

  “Not ‘talked’ to him, Jerry. Confessed to him. A little difference there. So you better check with this prized investigator of yours because he isn’t worth the county paycheck.”

  “Look, he told me the guy couldn’t read, so there was no way he could have gotten what he knew out of the discovery. He didn’t mention the photos.”

  “Exactly, and that’s why you should find yourself a new investigator. And I’ll tell you what, Jerry. I’m usually pretty reasonable about this sort of stuff. I try to go along to get along with the DA’s office. But I gave you fair warning about this guy. So after the break, I’m going to gut him right there on the stand and all you’re going to be able to do is sit there and watch.”

  I was in full outrage now, and a lot of it was real.

  “It’s called ‘rope a dope.’ But when I’m done with Torrance, he’s not the only one who’s going to look like a dope. That jury’s going to know that you either knew this guy was a liar or you were too dumb to realize it. Either way, you’re not coming off too good.”